Our shirts arrived in great condition. The box was very nice and sturdy and the tissue paper that is included is save-worthy. The shirt itself is super soft and very comfortable. I bought this for my husband to keep as a staple piece in his wardrobe and I'm so glad I did. The print is just "island-y" enough and not an overwhelming pattern. The color contrast of the print to the shirt is easy on the eyes :) My husband really loved the feel of the shirt. The stretch is forgiving enough to accommodate a slightly wider middle (heehee, dad bod, love it). We bought 2 other long sleeves with this as well. I only noticed the washing instructions when they arrived and am a little worried that it cannot be tumble dried low. We need to be extra mindful not to put ours in the dryer. Literally everything else we wear goes in the dryer so this might be hard to remember at all times. I only wish they could be tumble dried but other than that, I will definitely shop Buttercloth again!